I’ve been an X-Ways Forensics (XWF) user for just shy of four years. I’ll admit it now, I’m a fanboy. I love working with XWF and wouldn’t trade it for anything else. Despite having taken the XWF training course a few years ago, I’ve always felt like I wasn’t really using the software to its full potential. I was thrilled when co-author Brett Shavers told me about this book he was writing with Eric Zimmerman.
Shavers and Zimmerman are both well-known in the XWF community. I’ve seen their posts helping others and have received help from them myself when I’ve had questions about the software. I knew they were the right men for the job of writing this book.
XWF has a reputation (unfair in my opinion) of being difficult to use. Many practitioners are aware of how powerful the program is, but fear the dreaded learning curve. The X-Ways Forensics Practitioners Guide is meant to allay those fears, as well as teach veteran users a thing or two.
As an XWF user, I know the software is updated on a very frequent basis. According to the book:
"… there is an average of 41 days between new versions!". I wondered if this book could be written and truly remain relevant for long, given the regular updates and additions. After reading it, I believe the book will indeed remain relevant for future XWF versions. Though features are added and other things improved, the “basic” functionality of the program and the user interface remain familiar.
X-Ways Forensics Practitioners Guide has 10 chapters and two appendices. It begins with a brief history of X-Ways Forensics and its creator, Stefan Fleischmann. The intro also talks about the frequent XWF updates, as well as why they believe the book will be relevant and reliable guide for a long time to come. The remainder of the book is well organized and the chapters are logically arranged to get you from new user to completing an investigation.
Chapters one through three provide the reader with an excellent guide to getting the software installed and set up. One of the many things I like about the software is that you don’t have to actually install it. It will run from a usb thumb drive or from a complete install to Windows. The authors talk about the various ways XWF can be installed and run. The best way, in my opinion, is to “install” using the X-Ways Forensics Install Manager (XWFIM), a program written by book co-author Eric Zimmerman. XWFIM will download the version you wish to obtain, along with the appropriate viewer program. It also allows you to download the 32 bit, 64 bit or both versions and places them in the directory of your choice.
Chapter one also talks about setting up your dongle and introduces the user interface. It explains in nice detail what all the buttons are for. What I liked best about this chapter and the rest of the book, however, was the coverage of the various program options in which the authors provide their personal recommendations for the program settings. The program has so many choices, it’s helpful they provide these recommendations based on their own experience.
Chapter two covers Case Management and Imaging. The authors do a nice job of explaining how to set up a new case in XWF, explaining all the options in detail and offering advice on settings. They also cover the different types of disk imaging XWF can do and talk about file system support. I started using XWF for imaging about a year ago and like using it for that purpose. I have no numbers to back this up, but XWF just “seems faster” than other programs I’ve used for disk imaging. Again, the authors provide suggestions for optimal usage of the software.
Chapter two also talks about live response using XWF. I had the opportunity to use the program for that purpose not long ago when I was called to investigate a server intrusion with an unknown RAID configuration and owners unwilling to shut the server down. This type of use is covered, as is using a second instance of XWF to preview a system while your first instance is imaging the system during live response.
Chapter three is one of the most important chapters in the book. Extensive coverage of the program interface is provided, talking about left, middle and right click options, the Case Data Directory Tree and a great deal more. One part of the program I frequently find myself accessing is the Directory Browser Options, Filters dialog. The book covers each part of this dialog box and the authors again make recommendations for settings. XWF has, in many of its options, the choices of checked, unchecked or half-checked. These are described in detail and advice is given on how to make the most of them.
The next few chapters get into actually using the software. Using the Refine Volume Snapshot functions, hash databases and more are covered in chapters four and five.
One of the best, maybe the very best feature of XWF is the Refine Volume Snapshot function, covered in Chapter four. The RVS provides the means to perform file carving, extract file metadata and the contents of compressed files and more. Again, the book covers this feature in great detail, offering insight as to just what the volume snapshot is and what it means to refine it. Like all the chapters, screenshots of the various menus and options are included. A very nice graphic created by Ted Smith of the X-Ways Clips blog is included to help visualize the volume snapshot and refine volume snapshot functions.
The XWF Internal Hash Database and also the Registry Browser are talked about in Chapter five. I have used the hash database features since I first started using XWF, but I never used the Registry Browser. I normally rely on other software, such as RegDecoder and RegRipper for my registry investigation. I decided to give the XWF Registry Browser a look while reading this book and found it to be a pretty nice feature. Use of the hash database is explained very well, including how to create a database and the best ways to do your hashing.
Chapter six goes over the various means of searching using XWF. I’ve always known the search functions were very powerful, but I learned a lot from this chapter on ways I could search faster and with a greater likelihood of finding the data I’m searching for. I’ve always had difficulty grasping Regular Expressions and I was glad the authors took the time to cover their use in XWF. I came away from this chapter feeling like I had a much better chance of finding the data I need and with greater efficiency.
Advanced use of XWF is covered next. Ways to customize XWF configuration files, working with Hex and Timeline and Event Analysis is talked about through the first part of the chapter. Using the software to gather free and slack space is talked about next, along with RAM analysis. I had never used XWF for RAM analysis, preferring to use Volatility and perhaps occasionally Redline for that purpose. Once again, I learned some pretty good stuff about RAM analysis using XWF from this book and will definitely include the software in my investigations of RAM from here on.
One thing I had hoped to see in this book was a discussion of scripting for XWF. I’m not a programmer or script writer, but I have an interest in learning. While this is talked about somewhat, they are not covered as extensively as I had hoped. I do understand why they aren’t covered to a greater degree, as that would have deviated from the main point of the book and gotten into a how-to-program discussion.
The external analysis interface is next discussed. Again, I hadn’t used the function previously and learned how helpful it could be after reading this chapter.
Next up is Reporting in XWF. I’ve long appreciated the reporting capabilities and options in XWF and have used them many times. Just the same, I learned ways I could better take advantage of those capabilities.
The final two chapters cover the use of XWF in e-discovery and law enforcement investigations respectively. Methods of using the software to best conduct those investigations are talked about and suggestions/advice given. I’ve never done e-discovery, so I felt like I learned quite a bit from that chapter. The bulk of my forensics work is for Law Enforcement investigations and I found the chapter covered much of what I’d already been using the software for, although I’ll admit to learning a thing or two. Using XWF for on-scene triage is discussed, along with suggestions for use in probation searches. As pointed out in the book and as I’ve personally discovered, using XWF to triage a running system on-scene can be quite nice, helping you determine if full-disk encryption is in place.
Something else in the final chapter I have not yet tried is using XWF from a WinFE boot disk. I’ve not had much luck putting a WinFE disk together in the past, but admittedly haven’t spent a lot of time at it. Finally, Chapter 10 includes an example case to put what you’ve learned together in a practical sense.
Appendix A includes a nice collection of resources and shortcuts for XWF users. The great blogs of Ted Smith and Jimmy Weg are referred to, as well as a reference to some third party software. The remainder of this appendix is dedicated to keyboard shortcuts for use with XWF.
Finally, Appendix B is somewhat of an X-Ways FAQ chapter. This appendix is nice for a quick lookup of some commonly asked questions about the software.
Before ending this review, I wanted to talk about the writing style of the authors. This book doesn’t read like a dry, boring manual. It’s well written and easy to understand. I wonder sometimes how multiple authors can write a book and have it seem like it’s all written by one person. Cory and Harlan did a great job making Digital Forensics with Open Source Tools seem like a single author book and I have to say Brett and Eric did the same with this book. The text in both of those books flows well without seeming to jump from one person to another.
When I read a book and decide to review it, I ask myself a couple questions. First, did I learn from the book? Second, do I believe others will learn or benefit from the book? In this case, I have to say yes to both of those questions. This is the book the X-Ways community has needed for a long time. For those considering trying X-Ways, I strongly encourage you to buy this book. It will get you past the fear and trepidation some feel when they set out to use this great software and get you on the road to using it efficiently and successfully. For veteran users, I encourage you to buy it as well. As I said earlier, I’ve used XWF for nearly four years and feel quite comfortable with it. Still, I learned more than a just a little from reading this book and I’m betting you will too.
Thanks for the review Ken, very much appreciated. A side note on WinFE, I'll be posting updated info in a few weeks on building WinFE at http://winfe.wordpress.com that only requires a few commands and builds an iso in less than 5 minutes.
ReplyDeleteKen,
ReplyDelete...One thing I had hoped to see in this book...
Had you mentioned this to the authors prior to or while they were writing the book?
No, I must confess I did not.
ReplyDelete